Slide – Any educator that buys wall maps or globes should be fired

August 13, 2009 56 Comments

Share

Digitalmapping

Download this file: png ppt pptx

See also my other slides and the Great Quotes About Learning and Change Flickr pool.

UPDATE 1: In addition to the great comments below, see also my follow-up post.

UPDATE 2: We're having a slide remake contest! Deadline is Aug 22, 2009.

 

You might also like

  1. Slide – Who’s deciding your fate?
  2. “You’re fired. I only want people who already know how to do their jobs.”
  3. Slide – The times demand that we not settle for climbing ordinary mountains
  4. Slide – Lose your sleep before your decision, not after it
21st Century, Our Changing World, Slides, Teaching and Learning, Tech Integration

56 Responses to “Slide – Any educator that buys wall maps or globes should be fired”

  1. dlaufenberg Reply August 13, 2009 at 1:32 pm

    teacherninja and I agree…

    Just because you CAN access something digitally, doesn’t mean it is the only/best manner of consuming the information. Falling prey to the mantra of tech is always the better version can be dangerous to using the right tool at times… Since I have been teaching, there have been maps on my walls. Students are drawn to them, put their fingers over the rivers and borders… are curious. Paper maps have a place as does google earth/maps…

  2. teacherninja Reply August 13, 2009 at 1:03 pm

    No globes?

    I respectfully disagree. I’m all about Google maps as well, but my elementary students get a lot from globes.

  3. Daniel B. Hink Reply May 17, 2010 at 4:49 pm

    No Maps? Really?

    Clearly you are someone who has never navigated cross-country in tall forests, or in high mountains. And if you don’t understand the “why” of that comment then you are way out of your depth even talking about this subject.

    When you use technology without understanding what it’s foundation is, you do not understand the knowledge, or its origin.

    You are just a monkey who learned how to push the on-off button of the flashlight, you have no idea where the light comes from.

    Thankfully people who do care about maps and globes were around to create; GIS, GPS, etc. So you can now causally dismiss that hard earned knowledge.

    Do not fetishize technology, it is an ugly habit.

  4. Andrew B. Watt Reply May 19, 2010 at 8:47 pm

    The slide doesn’t say “no maps”. It says public money shouldn’t be spent on wall maps and globes.

    For the $400+ that a wall map of the ancient world costs, I got a Barrington Atlas of the Greek and Roman world for my classroom…. every archaeological site… every arena… every villa… every aqueduct…. every known latifundia… all in one book. Real data, combined with topographical information.

    For the same money, I could have gotten a rather vague map that showed the boundaries of the Roman empire, none of the provincial boundaries, none of the legion positions, and maybe a rough outline of the Sasanid empire. I know which set of maps I’d prefer.

    I use GIS, GPS, Google Earth and Yahoo Maps to show the ruins of Babylon and Uruk, and not just their positions on a Europe+Middle East map. I use them to show the route of Vasco DaGama around the Cape of Good Hope, and the ruins of the Portuguese slave trading forts, and the ruins of Kilwa, and the trading harbors of Mombasa and Calicut.

    I’d need hundreds of dollars worth of maps at multiple scales do do all of that, from a dozen different government agencies in a half-dozen different governments. And some might be classified. Or I can use a digital projector and the school’s internet connection.

    And I still teach my students to navigate with topo map and compass in the woods. That’s the appropriate technology for that environment… as Google Earth is in the classroom.

  5. Jackie Reply June 7, 2010 at 1:41 am

    And if something happens to LAN or net or system crashes, then we will not see where are ruins of Babylon and Uruk. I don’t have GPS and I like my globe! I am parent who take kids over the ocean, every year, to see something new and, learn part of world’s history. I can’t afford GPS (saving for trips), and I don’t care since, globe will do just fine for $5.00 and, I can bet my kids will know where on the map/globe is/was any state or country you can name, through history.

  6. Kirsten Reply June 23, 2010 at 8:08 pm

    After thinking about this a bit, I don’t take offense to the word “fired” as I did initially. It got my attention, and I needed to reflect. I am a teacher with over 20 years of experience, and I will be teaching for 20 more. I need to change and adapt my approach to facilitating my students’ learning which means using technology, as well as paper maps and globes, to access geographical information. I checked out the prices of globes and individual maps, and they are expensive. I think it is important for kids to have experience using them as tools and resources, but as I am currently learning, there is so much more I can do to engage my students with Google Maps and Google Earth. This slide just says to me that it is my responsibility as an educator to make sure that I move beyond my comfort zone and own experience as a student, and use the technology that is out there. It is irresponsible of me not to.

« Older Comments

Leave a Reply