Here is some good thinking about student usage of artificial intelligence from Debbie Millman:
A formed mind can argue or wrangle with the machine, reject its false polish and recognize when the language it constructs to redescribe the world has become too smooth or soulless. Someone who has lived with words long enough can sense when a sentence has not been earned, and someone who has already developed a voice can use the machine without allowing the machine to become the voice.
An unformed person may not know the difference, and that is also where danger lies. The obvious problem is cheating. But cheating is only the most visible and least interesting part of the problem. The more profound risk is that young people will use artificial intelligence to bypass the development of their own interior lives and fail to hone their actual intelligence.
We do not wait for children to turn 16 to hand them car keys because cars are evil, and we do not insist that surgeons train for years because scalpels are immoral. We build thresholds around powerful things because power requires judgment, and judgment can’t be downloaded or installed. Before a person asks a machine to write for them, they should know what it feels like to write from the depths of their own uncertainty and identity. Before a person lets a machine imitate their voice, they should have endured the long, uneven, often humiliating process of acquiring one.
If you are an educational technology advocate who is not subscribed to Audrey Watters’ Second Breakfast newsletter, you probably should be. I am going to just leave this quote here for us all to think about… (from her recent Un-Listed post)
I’ve long been a fan of Emily Bender and Alex Hanna‘s use of the phrase “synthetic text extruding machine” to talk about generative “AI.” It conjures an image of the pink slime that’s used in ultra-processed meat products – it’s not not meat, but yeah, ewww. But maybe I’m going to start saying “child porn machine” instead: “oh, did you use the child porn machine to summarize that article? Cooooool.” “oh, you used the child porn machine to grade your students’ essays? Niiiice.” “Ah, you had the child porn machine write letters to parents, praising their child’s behavior in class? Excellent.” “It’s faster to use the child porn machine to write letters-of-recommendation, you say? I see.” Nice school system, nice future you’re building.
Episode 005 of the new CASTLE Conversations podcast is now available on most major podcasting platforms. I had a super fun discussion with John Spencer, who helps educators and schools think about all sorts of cool stuff, including technology integration, AI, design thinking, and project-based learning.
Episode 003 of the new CASTLE Conversations podcast is now available on most major podcasting platforms. I talked with CASTLE Co-Director Sara Dexter, who helps educators and schools think about technology integration, leadership, AI, educator simulations, and digital case studies. Sara is super busy!
[I realized that I am way behind on posting recent podcast episodes, so I am catching up!]
Recently I had the opportunity to appear on the Education Matters podcast with Jason Buccheri. Jason was an awesome host and we talked for a long time about deeper learning, models of organizational change, reclaiming joy in school, empowering students through technology, and … surprise, AI! … among other topics. Also, Jason has superb production skills if you ever need podcasting assistance or training. I hope that the episode is useful to you.
Her class at Southwest Miami Senior High School had already read about John F. Kennedy and discussed his campaign for “new frontier” economic and social policies. Now Ms. Lowd asked two dozen 11th graders to open their laptops and type a prompt into Google’s Gemini chatbot: “Act like President Kennedy. What was the new frontier?”
The chatbot quickly spat out paragraphs of Kennedyesque text, including phrases like “my fellow Americans.”
Then Ms. Lowd asked her students to analyze whether the chatbot simulations accurately reflected the Kennedy speeches they had studied. The teenagers’ verdict: The simulations were “awkward,” “weird” and yet still credible.
“It did a very good job of impersonating J.F.K.,” said Ashley Acedo, 17.
In some recent AI workshops for educators, I’ve been doing quick Great or Gimmick? scenarios. One of them happens to be about AI chatbots impersonating historical figures. Leaving aside teenage Ashley’s ability to discern whether or not AI did a good job of impersonating President Kennedy (are they a JFK scholar?), what do we think about these historical figure AI bots? I confess that I’m skeptical…
Colorado educators! (and anyone else within reasonable driving distance… looking at you, Nebraska, Wyoming, Kansas, New Mexico, and maybe Utah and Oklahoma!)
We hope that you will join us for our June 2025 Teacher Leader Summit in Denver. On Thursday, June 5, we will be leaning into instructional redesign for deeper learning. On Friday, June 6, we will fold artificial intelligence into the mix. Individuals are invited but teams are encouraged. Register soon!
—
THURSDAY, JUNE 5. Redesigning Lessons for Deeper Learning and Student Engagement
As much as we’re worried about ‘learning loss,’ our students aren’t going to learn if they’re not first engaged. Let’s create reasons for students to come to school and opportunities to do things that are interesting! In our Day 1 workshop, we will use the free 4 Shifts Protocol to redesign lessons, units, and other instructional activities for critical thinking and problem solving, greater student agency, more real-world authentic work, and robust technology infusion. In the afternoon we will connect a number of blended learning and ‘science of learning’ strategies to this redesign work. We also will peek inside some deeper learning schools around the country to see how they’re approaching this instructional design work.
Participant Outcomes
Participants will walk away with the following knowledge, skills, and resources (based on empirical research from 90+ deeper learning schools, not just anecdotes, and design work with tens of thousands of educators):
The ability to use the 4 Shifts Protocol to redesign lessons and units for higher student engagement and deeper learning
The ability to use the 4 Shifts Protocol as a curriculum planning resource, not just an instructional design tool
Numerous exemplars of deeper learning in action
On-ramp strategies to help schools and design teams get started on their new learner profiles or graduate portraits
Techniques and suggestions for navigating instructional, curricular, and organizational speed bumps and roadblocks
Key instructional mindsets and design behaviors
Discussion questions for teaching staff, leadership teams, and families
—
FRIDAY, JUNE 6. AI, Schools, and Deeper Learning
Artificial intelligence (AI) – particularly generative AI – is rapidly transforming how we learn, work, and create, while simultaneously sparking grave concerns about the ongoing balance between humans and machines. In our Day 2 workshop, we will explore a multitude of instructional, productivity, and ethical considerations related to AI and teaching, and we will connect everything back to what we did in Day 1.
Through a series of practice-based scenarios, we will explore day-to-day implementation considerations, and see if we also can maybe make the lives of students and teachers a little easier and more productive. There will be ample opportunities to explore and share together throughout the day. Let’s roll up our sleeves and pe into both the possibilities and pitfalls of these powerful digital tools. Participants will walk away with a number of useful resources and ideas for sparking conversations in their local communities. Please bring your own examples and use cases of how you’re using AI!
Participant Outcomes
Participants will walk away with the following knowledge, skills, and resources (based on extensive technology integration and leadership work with schools and educators):
The ability to use AI to enhance our teaching efficiency and productivity
Creative pedagogical uses of AI across all grade levels
The ability to think about instructional and ethical concerns such as attribution, plagiarism, cheating, lack of transparency, privacy, bias, and erosion of critical thinking
Understanding how AI works and expected advancements in the future
Exposure to numerous AI tools and their potential capabilities, possibilities, limitations, and biases
Strategies and suggestions for talking about AI with fellow educators, students, and families
Yesterday James Bedford reached out to me, noting that my AI vicious cycle was very similar to his AI Wheel of Death and asking me to give him proper attribution. Of course I was immediately horrified that I might have misappropriated James’ intellectual property…
Thanks for sharing. I have heard a number of educators articulating [verbally] the ideas that were encapsulated in my wheel, which is why I finally decided to just make it. We all are struggling with how to keep the humanity in learning and teaching. I’m guessing that somewhere along the chain you helped spark those ideas that are now bouncing around the educational ecosphere. As Dean Shareski has noted, we are all derivatives of others’ brilliance and sharing.
I always want to give attribution where it’s due. I’ve changed both the blog post and the graphic. See if this will work for you?
There are so many ideas and images floating around out there, and sometimes it is extremely difficult to know where something came from, even for those of us who consider ourselves savvy Internet and social media veterans. Mistakes and oversights happen. But if we have a chance to make it right, we always should do so.
Thank you, James, for the graciousness with which you approached me, and for sparking some great educator conversations that somehow, over the many months, eventually made their way to me (even if I didn’t know it!).